Ask. Share. Get Work Done.™
The information contained herein is for informational purposes only and is not legal, tax, financial nor other professional advice or counsel. The information may or may not reflect the most current legal, tax, financial or other developments and, accordingly, it is not promised or guaranteed to be correct or complete. Proformative and its users expressly disclaim all liability in respect to actions taken or not taken based on any of the contents of this website. This website is not intended to create, and does not create, a professional-to-client relationship nor does it ensure confidentiality between you and Proformative or between any of its users, and you should not act or rely on any information in this website. For more information please see the website’s User Agreement.
You must register or login to see the full content on this page (including all comments). It's free, quick, and easy.

CFO/Controller without a CPA

User's Picture

Details

Two-part question/discussion about being a CFO/Controller without a CPA, primarily from the small/private company perspective:  

1)  Besides bulletins from/consultations with your external accountants (and Proformative discussion boards), any other key resources/tips for keeping on top of emerging accounting issues?

2)   When job-hunting, how do you deal with a CPA "requirement"?  If it's "required" in a job description, do you address it in your cover letter or just tell your best story and hope to be able to get to an interview to sell yourself?  How do you answer the question in an interview?

I don't have any great tips for (1), I generally just rely on generic internet searches to try to figure something out, then discuss with our accountants as needed.

For (2), I typically use an example of a complex contract -- explain that I write up a proposed accounting treatment and review it with auditors for approval before making the accounting entries (or even before the contract is signed if we are counting on a particular accounting treatment).  Then I emphasize that I wouldn't do anything differently even if I were a CPA -- it is simply "best practice" to handle it at the time the matter arises than at audit, regardless of CPA status.

Also, mentioning an emerging issue (eg FAS 123R) can illustrate that both CPAs and non-CPAs are in the same boat for new regulations -- both need to come up to speed, and CPA status is neither a requirement nor a substitute for doing so.

Other thoughts from this perspective, or from a hiring manager's perspective?

Comments

User's Picture

Thoughts on CPA designation

To your first question, I get an email from the AICPA every day that is a nic...

User's Picture

Good approach!

Andrea:

Been there, done that. I have been a CFO many times and withou...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

I think Bryan's got it right on getting past HR and recruiters when a job lis...

User's Picture

CFO must be CPA?

I think for public companies the Board only hires CFOs that are CPAs. Same f...

User's Picture

CFO must be CPA?

Either person can go to equal rights prison and jail cell. The courts don't ...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement.

Obviously the CPA designation is of value to employers or they would not be a...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

My observations concerning the two questions asked.

First, there are m...

User's Picture

CPA requirement

I have been a CFO many times and each time the job description had CPA in it ...

User's Picture

Controller without a CPA

Jeff, I am currently assessing the ROI of getting my CPA designation. I have ...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller without CPA

Since the above responses cover the area quite well I will keep my response b...

User's Picture

Very well said! Could not

Very well said! Could not agree more.

...
User's Picture

CFO/Controller without CPA

Many of the comments have two themes. The first theme primarily from CFOs wi...

User's Picture

Current job market

In the current job market, it will be very difficult to get an interview for ...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

Agree with Jim's comment, and would like to offer my perspective as someone w...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller w/o a CPA

Last spring, CFO magazine had an article about CFO without a CPA. They found...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller w/o as CPA

I have been a CFO for multi national companies more than 20 years without a C...

User's Picture

CFO without a CPA

I have worked as a CFO without a CPA for several companies. The primary reaso...

User's Picture

CFO CPA

I would agree, John, that there are situations where a non-CPA can win a job ...

User's Picture

CFO / CPA

I posted this question on the CFO group on Linked In. John asked me to re-pos...

User's Picture

CFO/CPA

No, I do not hold a CPA but have just completed a Group CFO role in Russia. I...

User's Picture

CPA being an inhibitor

Interesting question posed by Cindy. I have a CPA and I do feel that at time...

User's Picture

CPA as a limiter

No way-I have held several positions that were not primarily financial includ...

User's Picture

strategic input

It has been my experience that it largely depends on a business's corporate s...

User's Picture

CFO/CPA

I believe there is an alternative certification to a CPA that has value in in...

User's Picture

CFO/CPA

I don't have a CPA but everytime I went for an interview that required a CPA ...

User's Picture

Comptroller General

So I wonder how you feel about the discussion going around Congress and the A...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

As a CPA, I must tell you that you are correct that just because one has a CP...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

Lisa

I disagree on both fronts of the arguement '...CPA is a subject m...

User's Picture

CPA Requirement

John, I agree that just having a CPA license does not provide the necesary to...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller w/o CPA designation

I agree with practically all of the above comments.

I operated first a...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller without a CPA - Requirements of firm

Many companies assign the same meaning to the terms CFO and Controller. I fo...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller without a CPA - Requirements of firm

Mark;

Wow! That is fantastic, not only has the difference been articu...

User's Picture

CFO/Controller comparison chart

Very good chart. The chart makes it clear that strategy related items rest w...

User's Picture

chart

I like your chart Mark. But what is your opinion on the evolvement of the con...

User's Picture

Chart - Evolution of Controller role

In the comments above, Randal Shields makes a very relevant remark in the gro...

User's Picture

Comparision Chart

Dear Mark,

Your chart is useful and simple to understand. By using thi...

User's Picture

CONTROLLER/CFO WITHOUT CPA

Having seen CPAs whose accounting skills were marginal, and non-CPAs whose sk...

User's Picture

CPA requirement for CFO

I am an experienced public company Controller and an experienced public compa...