more-arw search

Q&A Forum

How can I improve financial and operational accuracy?

I manage the life cycle of finance at the head office as well as 7 subsidiaries. My main challenge has been with accuracy of reporting and operational efficiencies. A PO is raised and approved for all transactions before it can be expensed. However nature of our business exposes us to having Pos raised in retrospect (which debunks the whole idea of the PO in the first place) or we could have either a last minute cancellation or emergencies that would incur extra time therefore POs are not always accurate. We also get late invoices from suppliers which means we have to make accruals for month end reporting and sometimes, 3month old invoices turn up from self-employed workers, meaning we have to always review past accounts every now and then. Processing is done via spreadsheet and accounting software, sage50 (double work), but it helps to reduce duplicate invoices by 80% (human error during processing). On the income side, we have two modes of income, one is guaranteed contract payment and the other is self generating payment, where each of the subsidiaries provide similar services, to customers who usually pay 60% by cash/cheque and 40% by BACs. Most of the customers are not repeat customer and every month we could average 80 customers per subsidiary. A spreadsheet is used to monitor services because all accounting functions are carried out at the head office. This leads to inability to track income accurately as only what is seen on the spreadsheet is recorded as income. Sometimes services may have been provided over 3 months before payment is made and head office may not be aware, so rather than have an accurate double entry processing, we combine both. On the contract payment, it is usually hard to track when payment will be received for certain aspects of the services we provide and matching payment is mainly dependent on contract statement which shows income net of claw backs, unfortunately, all claw backs also have to be shown on the accounting system as an expense, while all income have to be coded to specific line items on the P&L. What can I do to improve this situation, improve accuracy or reporting income and expenses while also improving operational efficiency across subsidiaries, so that all processes are streamlined and any new accounting officer will not have to go through the complexity of our accounting system. It really worries me because I believe there can be a better way to improve the whole system that I have inherited, which will save countless hours of lost time and loss of productivity. Please advice.


Topic Expert
Patrick Dunne
Title: Chief Financial Officer
Company: Milk Source
(Chief Financial Officer, Milk Source) |

Sounds like you have some fun challenges. I think the first solution is doing nothing more than requiring all transactions to be input on the system immediately. Let's discuss A/P first....If a PO isn't used, or in other words, if someone is not complying, tell them payment to their vendor will be delayed. This should get their attention and if there are any training issues, they may self correct. You have to use system controls that Sage provides, but you can add some sequential numbering or other review processes to ensure accuracy.

I am not too familiar with Sage, but on the revenue side, you need to get to the point of establishing a customer master (with appropriate controls). Sage should have a project or work order process where you can log all revenue as orders are received. Require all new business to be logged or an order is entered.

Based on what you described, there has to be leakage across the organization (duplicate payments, unbilled work). You need to start from ground zero and ensure these basic controls are prevalent, or you will be battling symptoms rather than the cause.

Toyin A
Title: Finance Administrator
Company: CHL
LinkedIn Profile
(Finance Administrator, CHL) |

Thanks Patrick. I have provided training and sent letters to majority of our supplier telling them not to provide services without a PO because it could cause delays. All my managers across sites have also been informed of possible delays to payment if they don't provide suppliers with PO but it hasn't stopped invoices coming in without PO. I then have to go into the PO system to find a possible matching PO which takes me off my core tasks. Unfortunately we are a growing business and our Sage license only covers head office and and therefore usage across sites is impossible. Thats why I created an income tracker to all the managers unfortunately thats not being used properly even after training has been provided. You are correct theres income leakage and I am tasked with resucing or eliminating these as well. This is indeed a fun challenge but it would be more fun if I can correct it and make the system less complicated.

(Director) |

Well said Pat.

J.G. Collins
Title: Managing Director
Company: The Stuyvesant Square Consultancy
(Managing Director, The Stuyvesant Square Consultancy) |

You may need to do a high-level review and ask some critical questions; the type I would ask if you were a cllient.:

"Why do you have seven subsidiaries "where each of the subsidiaries provide similar services"? Is it really necessary to have seven or could they (ideally) be rolled up into one or some other fewer number. Why seven?

If there is some critical need for seven companies (e.g., they're overseas subsidiaries) then I would ask:

"Why can't we do our billing and procurement through a shared services agreement, where we have a stand alone company whose sole purpose is billings, collections, payroll, etc. that are billed out at FMV to the subsidiaries?"

These are big picture issues that should be addressed, first, by you and, perhaps, with your company's counsel or management. After that, you should consider pitching the notions of (a) a single company with operating divisions; or (b) a single corporate services company to senior management..

Not a quick answer by any means. (If you're calendar, you'd be looking at a change, probably, at the earliest January 1, 2015, although it could be done earlier but with higher higher compliance costs.) But the long-term benefits would be invaluable in terms of efficiencies and control, and also offer a quick payback.

Topic Expert
Bob Scarborough
Title: CEO
Company: Tensoft, Inc.
(CEO, Tensoft, Inc.) |

A few thoughts that may be helpful:

1) PO/Payable Processes
* Controlling supplier behavior along with internal behavior is challenging. Most people - most companies that are not in the Fortune 2000 - have less than total leverage over people.
* PO processes are designed to include approval for significant expenses prior to them occurring. They also add administrative overhead to your company - so there is a cost for these processes. Given the challenges of your PO system you could benefit from narrowing the areas where they are needed. Sometimes people use corporate purchase plans (with credit cards) for people with spending authority to distribute pre-authorized spending plans (up to $X per month based on your need).
* Independent contractors are a unique challenge. They are often independent for a reason – and at the same time you are not hiring them for a reason. They aren’t going to work to the same standard as internal employees. What we have found works best is standard requests for invoices to all independent contractor every week. Most of these folks respond to personal touch but not a corporate policy. This is the sort of thing that could be pushed to all of the subsidiaries.

2) Leveraging Sage 50. I’m not familiar with the product or the licensing model. However most on premise solutions are licensed by the site (installation on a specific server) and not by the number of subsidiaries or legal entities tracked in the system. To expand access to this system you could move the product to a cloud/hosting platform or put technology in place internally to support broader access to your system. You need to check your license agreement – I’m guessing you are a technical solution away from broad access.
3) Revenue and Invoicing Processes
* It sounds like this is a dynamic and flexible process. It also is what drives your company forward. Leveraging your financial solution to do invoicing would be a start (getting customers setup and billed in the system).
* To streamline this you could look one step back to your sales process. Do you leverage internal resources or outside contractors? Or are these eCommerce type sales? Whatever the go to market model it could benefit from its own software to support the process – some type of CRM solution potentially. You can then look at integrating the sales process (prospect to customer, quote to invoice). This would have the added benefit of exposing the sales pipeline to you to support your internal financial projections.

Bob Scarborough

Toyin A
Title: Finance Administrator
Company: CHL
LinkedIn Profile
(Finance Administrator, CHL) |

Thanks Bob and J.G. Collins. Your suggestions are very insightful. They are a real eye opener to better alternatives. I will incorporate them into my plans for the new year. Change is tough but it is necessary especially in my situation. The earlier I streamlined the process the better is for the company and me.

Martin Buckle
Title: Owner
Company: Bjorklund & Company of Canada Ltd
(Owner, Bjorklund & Company of Canada Ltd) |

This problem must be enormously frustrating for you but when you have improved the process you will be able to use it to demonstrate the value you bring to your company. I would take a moment to prepare a change management plan for the issue: the problem seems obvious, the benefit from resolving it seems obvious yet change hasn't happened, so you need to understand why? What is stopping people from making the change to a smoother system? Take the time to understand the root cause of the missing documentation: is it simply a software issue? Is it remoteness from the central office? Are people being rewarded for the wrong actions? What KPIs do they see?

I would also be aware that the needs of the finance department are sometimes seen as pointless bureaucracy so ask yourself what support you need: do you need a change champion at each location? Do you need the CEO to send out your communications so that people understand it is a corporate objective not just a finance nice-to-have?

As I said earlier, when you have resolved this issue it will be a highlight of your career so I wish you good luck.

Toyin A
Title: Finance Administrator
Company: CHL
LinkedIn Profile
(Finance Administrator, CHL) |

Thanks Martin. I completely agree with you. When I resolve this issue it will be a real turning point in my career. Its one of the reasons I have reached out to top professionals on this platform and I am glad that I have received great advice that will set the ball rolling for me.

Products and Companies

Get Free Membership

By signing up, you will receive emails from Proformative regarding Proformative programs, events, community news and activity. You can withdraw your consent at any time. Contact Us.

Business Exchange

Browse the Business Exchange to find information, resources and peer reviews to help you select the right solution for your business.

Learn more

Contribute to Community

If you’re interested in learning more about contributing to your Proformative community, we have many ways for you to get involved. Please email [email protected] to learn more about becoming a speaker or contributing to the blogs/Q&A Forum.